I’m sorry God, but I think you’re crazy.
_
Mystery of God
I was 27 years old when I nearly walked away from God. It did not happen in the clutches of a wayward woman. It didn’t come in the aftermath of some drunken rebellion. It didn’t even follow some great tragedy or misfortune. No, this darkness, this flooding void, came as a leach upon something very good. Theology.
For me theology was life and death. It was not something to simply peruse and browse and set aside when the hour became late or the topic too deep. It was a map; the very map which made life possible. Setting it aside not only admitted defeat, it stopped all progress. It felt as if my life would lose all meaning if I ran upon something I could not understand.
This was foolish of course, because it was inevitable I would encounter such a challenge. But I believed it was simply a lack of effort which prevented people from reaching true understanding. I would not give up, so it seemed fair to expect such a derailment was perfectly avoidable.
I recall the sermon vividly. Our pastor was trying to convince a reluctant congregation that predestination was a tremendous blessing. Towards the end of the sermon he used an example to help illustrate the fruits of this theology. He described a father watching his child play on the sidewalk in front of their house. As the young boy is kicking the ball, he loses control of it and it rolls into the street. The father, sensing disaster, runs and grabs the boy a split second before he lunges into the path of a speeding truck.
The pastor finished the story with a big confident smile. A smile that made it very clear this story was supposed to make us very happy. This was the moment we were to say praise the Lord, it all makes sense now. I looked around a bit, hoping I wasn’t the only one who didn’t feel the joy. Someone else who heard the same story but came away with a different conclusion.
The audience seemed divided. Some I could see accepted the news with great thankfulness, a ready affirmation to their belief. Others looked quietly distraught, a simmering confusion boiling beneath the surface. I was not confused. I was horrified.
The pastor went on to explain how the father represents God and we are the child. And this is a metaphor to our story of salvation, how God reaches down and plucks us from certain disaster. This was very confusing to me. It seemed like only half the story. And of the two halves, by far the only one that is presentable enough to explain from the pulpit.
I leaned over to the person sitting next to me and asked what about the other boy, the one who the father sat back and watched run in front of the Mack truck? If I was the kid, I hardly think the joy of avoiding my own death would equal the despair of my watching my father let my brother die.
I wanted to ask the pastor what he thought. I wanted to stop the sermon, stand up and ask about the brother. What should we think of him? A sacrificial pawn? Perhaps just some unfortunate cost of doing business?
I didn’t. I sat in my chair and seethed. It was one thing to come against some confusing aspect of God’s nature. Some seeming contradiction between two descriptions of our Father. But quite another to be told it ought to make perfect sense.
I think it was the presentation that sat so coldly. The easy calmness, the smug projection of self assuredness. A tone of pity telling me that my intellect was too soft and infantile to accept such a truth.
The sermon ended, the worship band played a few songs and we shuffled outside. On the way to my car I caught a friend with a tear in her eye. We spoke for a bit and it was clear she had found the same dark side of the story. She told me if this was how God really was, then He wasn’t a God worth worshipping. I nodded my head, unwilling to disagree.
I drove home. Anger and confusion casting a pallid shadow over all my thoughts. I had been here before, I knew the terrain well. But it did little to keep the devil at bay. It simply couldn’t be. How could a loving God create people for the sole purpose of eternal suffering without any chance of repentance? If this were true, the whole thing seemed meaningless.
Why should I get out of bed? Why should I tell my neighbor about the gospel? And perhaps even more so, why should I worship? Does the praise of a robot truly delight the Father’s ear? I suppose it may, and if it does, I can only protest, He is still God. And He may still ask me to praise Him. I imagine I still would, but it would be as a slave bows to his cruel master. A movement of actions but not of the heart.
But there was some truth to it. I found it in scripture. Often, right next to a verse describing free will and choice. This almost made it worse because it kept me from throwing out the idea in its entirety. That would be much simpler. I could just call myself an Arminian and find another church. But no, however distasteful, it was clearly there and must be faced.
Over the next days and weeks a dramatic shift careened through my life. This single idea, this theological wrecking ball wielded such power it consumed all light from my relationship with God. God was still there, I never walked away from the belief in His power, in His existence. But now He sat upon a different throne. A black throne in a black cave.
I wish I could say the answer came through further study. Some brilliant theological deduction that brought the conflicting pieces together. Some answer that held free will and God’s sovereignty in perfect union. It simply never came. Hours and days I poured over scripture, books, sermons, looking for a logical answer.
After weeks of fruitless searching, I simply quite. I gave up. Set aside the books and gave up. It became clear to me that pursuing this any further was bringing me dangerously close to a point of no return. A moment when the confusion would put to death all belief. A kind of spiritual panic attack when fears and assumptions are taken to ridiculous extremes.
In the end it was a decision. A cold force of will to declare the topic off limits. Perhaps to be revisited during a time of greater spiritual strength. At first it felt like defeat, like I was quitting out of a pathetic mental weakness.
Yet this weakness turned into great solace. A few weeks later, after I regained some composure, I realized a great truth. There is a purpose in God’s mystery. If I understood it all, if it all made perfect cohesive sense, what would that mean? I would be God.
This acceptance brought tremendous freedom. And even more than freedom I found a certain joy. A release from the burden of predicating my love for Jesus on my understanding for His actions.
The more I dug, the more aspects of life I found stained by a refusal to accept this truth. How many times had I judged God, launching criticisms in a moment of haste because His actions didn’t make sense. A broken relationship, a lost job, an uncured disease. All blame laid at His feet because it didn’t fit into my explanation.
I returned to scripture, but now I found something very different. The stories, the parables, the teachings, they all made much more sense in light of His divine mystery. I realized there was a reason He taught in parables rather than systematic theology. At some level, He must delight in Him being God and us being humans. And with this, delight in the chasm between our understanding.
He asked me to simply be a human. Accept my limitations, love Him and love those around me. And learn to love Him at a much more basic level. Love Him not because I understood His perfect plan, but because I first believed that He loved me. That in His very nature was a loving and just God.
The doubts and confusion remain to this day. I imagine they will always be a part of my faith. But they have lost their power. Still questions to ponder and wrestle, but never again will they throw their claws around the Father Himself.
Posted: February 27th, 2009 under mystery of god.
Tags: mystery
Comments: 8